How To: Persistent 3D Print Failure? Here’s What To Look For

By on November 3rd, 2017 in learning

Tags: , ,

 A failed 3D print
A failed 3D print

The problem: you keep printing an item on your desktop 3D printer but it always fails. Solution? Read on.

I’ve seen this plenty of times when using plastic extrusion 3D printers and have come to realize there are several standard issues that might be causing the problem. It’s considerably frustrating as prints may take quite a while to complete and you’re wasting much time as well as filament. 

The situation is common: you start a print to run overnight and in the morning you check the 3D printer only to find a pile of spaghetti. Even worse, melted – and now solidified – plastic might be embedded in the components of your machine. In the worst case you might actually wreck your machine. 

It’s best to avoid these situations. Here’s a few things to consider if you’re having consistent problems printing a particular 3D model. 

Bed Level? The most obvious problem you may encounter is that your print surface may be slightly unlevel. This means that in part of your 3D print’s first layer the extruder will be too high, while in the rest it will be too low. For a very small portion of the print surface it will be at the correct height. For machines that do not have an auto level function, you should ensure the machine is in fact level. 

In some extreme cases the print surface itself is bent and thus cannot be properly leveled. This tends to happen only in older machines with non-metal print beds, such as acrylic. 

ACTION: Level your print surface using the standard approach for your machine. 

Z-Gap Wrong? Even when a desktop 3D printer is completely level, there is still the matter of ensuring the gap between the nozzle and the print surface is optimum. If it’s too much, then the first layer will not be sticking properly and likely will come loose later on. If it’s too tight you may find the print sticking too much when completed, or in some cases the extrusion may stop due to back pressure from a very tight squeeze pushing the filament. 

ACTION: Set the z-gap properly with a test print. Some machines actually allow you to tweak this on the fly, which you should almost always do during the first layer. 

 Another failed 3D print
Another failed 3D print

Print Surface Unclean: Very often people are handling the print surface and inadvertently leaving oils and other material. You can’t necessarily see it, but it can affect the adhesion properties of some plastics. There’s also the possibility of crud leftover from previous prints should should be removed. Each new print should face an unpolluted print bed. 

ACTION: clean the print bed with appropriate solutions. Usually this means isopropyl alcohol, but check with your 3D printer manufacturer. 

Filament Snagging? The plastic extrusion 3D printer will work only so long as filament is being delivered to the extruder. This means that your filament spool should rotate smoothly without much effort. Sometimes you can find the spool having too much friction on its mount, which can put undue stress on the extruder that could even slip. 

ACTION: Ensure the spool rotates smoothly and even lubricate if necessary. 

Knots: Another possibility is that the filament itself is knotted up. This occurs when you accidentally let the end of the filament slip underneath other strands, typically when changing spools. 

ACTION: Always hold on to the loose end of the filament and stick it in the holes in the filament spool. For untangling, try this.

Flat Bottom? A print will stick if there is sufficient surface area on the bottom of the 3D model. But although your 3D model might LOOK like it’s flat, it may NOT BE SO. If this is the case, you might be surprised to find your first layer is fantastically smaller than you thought and is insufficient to stick. 

ACTION: Use a 3D modeling tool to inspect the bottom of the 3D model before printing. If necessary, use a Plane Cut to slice off a wee bit of the bottom to ensure it’s truly flat. 

Enough Bottom? What is the ratio of surface area of the bottom to the rest of the print? Do you expect to 3D print a large object and have only a 4mm square area support it? I think not. 

ACTION: Make sure the bottom of the 3D model is sufficient to support the rest of the model. Reorient if necessary. 

Temperature Correct? Sometimes layers aren’t sticking together properly in mid print and depending on the model’s geometry it might cause a failure. This could be because you’re 3D printing at a temperature that’s a bit too low. 

ACTION: Increase the print temperature slightly and ensure those layers really fuse into each other. 

First Layer Adhering? You hit print and walked away, believing the print would actually work? Hahah, you should NEVER do that! 

ACTION: Always, always, always observe at least the first layer of the print to ensure there is a good, strong base for the remainder of the print to build on. 

Supports too Tall? Some 3D models require support structures, but depending on the geometry, the supports might be very, very tall and very, very fragile. It’s possible they’ll tip over before they get to the part they were supposed to support, simply by the actions of the extruder moving along the top. 

ACTION: Look at the support tool path in a GCODE viewer and decide if it’s really too tall. If so, consider changing the support structure in your slicing tool to be more robust, or reorienting the 3D model to reduce the size of the supports. Another option: Meshmixer supports

Wrong Material? Very often you’ll see warped prints, typically starting at the corners of the 3D model. This is caused by the thermoplastic shrinking slightly, and this effect is amplified over long axes. You’ll usually see the ends of a long piece lifting. If they lift too much they could detach entirely from the print bed and cause print failure. 

ACTION: Consider printing in a less warp-prone material like PLA instead of ABS, or using a 3D printer with a heated chamber. 

That’s the list, but I am sure there are more failure possibilities. However, these are the ones I hit most often. 

Know them, and they won’t burn you. 

By Kerry Stevenson

Kerry Stevenson, aka "General Fabb" has written over 8,000 stories on 3D printing at Fabbaloo since he launched the venture in 2007, with an intention to promote and grow the incredible technology of 3D printing across the world. So far, it seems to be working!